Back to home

The Strips

Court rulings turned into comics — a flip-through noir album.

Real rulings in noir · click the halves to flip →

THE DEVIL'SSTRIPSNo.XIII — The Guarantor Dies, the Debt LivesA real ruling, word for word.Trib. Taranto · Div. II · 10.6.2026 · n. 1193click on the right to flip through →
THE DEBTORA current account in Martina Franca.Opened in 2014.My husband, guarantor up to €260,000.Current account n. 103057254, Martina Franca branch. Credit line securedby the husband's guarantee, up to €260,000.
THE DEBTOR29 February 2024: my husband dies.I don't tell the bank.The account stays open five more months.The credit line continues for five months after the death, with the bank unaware.On 31.7.2024 the loan is revoked. The account closes in the red: €87,206.46.
€THE BANKTHE DEBTORPetition filed 8 November.Order issued 11 November.Debtor and guarantor, jointly.The guarantor has been deadfor eight months. The orderagainst him doesn't exist.The payment order is requested and issued when the guarantor has been dead for months.The challenger seeks its non-existence — against him, and cascading to herself.
JUDGE · LentiAgainst the dead guarantor:the order doesn't exist.Against you, debtor:it stands. Art. 1292 c.c.Heart of the ruling: the collapse of the title against the deceased guarantor doesn't dischargethe main debtor. The creditor may claim the whole from any joint co-debtor.
THE DEBTORTHE JUDGESummon the heirs!I want my husband's guarantees!The guarantee protectsthe bank, not you.The choice is theirs, not yours.In guarantee-based joint liability the interest is individual, not collective: the creditor may suejust one co-debtor (art. 1306 c.c.). No necessary joinder (Cass. 23422/2016).
ADVOCATUS DIABOLITHE JUDGEBut wasn't the guaranteemeant to protect her?No. It protects the creditor.The debtor stays outsidethat relationship, art. 1936 c.c.Unequal joint liability (art. 1298 c.c.): a guarantor who pays has recourse against the debtor,never the reverse. The bank may choose not to pursue the guarantor's heirs — that's its call.
€THE BANKTHE JUDGEContract, account statements,formal notice of default.All produced.No specific challengefrom the debtor.Debt proven.The debtor challenges neither the existence nor the amount: burden of proof discharged by the bank,no extinguishing or impeding fact raised under art. 2697 c.c.
JUDGE · LentiNon-existent against the guarantor.That order is revoked.But you, debtor, pay:€87,206 plus interest.P.Q.M.: declares the payment order against the deceased guarantor non-existent and revokes it;dismisses the debtor's challenge on the merits, ordering €87,206.46 plus contractual interest (capped by the usury ceiling). Taranto, 10.6.2026.
THE DEVIL'S POSTSCRIPTpro-veritate opinionA guarantee is not a life raft for the debtor:it's a weapon in the creditor's hand, and only they decide to use it.If the guarantor dies, the debt doesn't die with them —it stays whole on whoever signed first.And if the bank chooses not to chase the guarantor's heirs,no one can force it: the choice between two estatesbelongs to the creditor, not to a debtor hoping for a shortcut.Moral: not telling the bank about a death doesn't erasea debt. It simply leaves it all on your own shoulders.ADVOCATUS DIABOLI
THE GUARANTOR IS GONE.The debt remains.The guarantee was for the bank, never for you.— Trib. Taranto, Div. II, 10.6.2026, n. 1193 · Advocatus Diaboli

😈 «Her husband, guarantor up to €260,000, dies. She doesn't tell the bank: the account stays open five more months. When the order arrives, the guarantor has been dead for eight months — against him it doesn't exist. But against her, the whole debt remains: the guarantee was for the bank, never for the debtor.»

Cover

☕ « If you'd like to buy me a coffee, the link is somewhere around the site… alas, my London colleagues turn it straight into beer 🍺. » 😈😈 …but a smile remains 😏🙂

LE STRISCEDEL DIAVOLON.XIIIThe Guarantor Dies, the Debt Lives

Archive

The Guarantor Dies, the Debt Lives

Trib. Taranto · Sez. II · 10.6.2026 · n. 1193

Back to home